The Ups and Downs of Parking Lot Control Arms


My workplace is contacted many occasions a month relating to a car parking zone management arm or barrier gate damage of some kind. These phrases are usually interchangeable; nonetheless, some requirements don’t use the time period management arm, solely barrier arm. Normally, the legal professional begins by explaining that the plaintiff was hit by a descending car parking zone arm with none advance warning. Generally the injured social gathering is using a motorbike, generally strolling as a pedestrian below the arm. In different claims the gate arm doesn’t absolutely cycle open earlier than returning to the horizontal place. There are additionally circumstances the place the gate seems to have been left in an open place, turned off, and is remaining within the upright place for prolonged intervals of time and immediately descends simply as a pedestrian begins to cross below it. There are quite a few variations of the identical kind of accident, however there are huge variations in who the accountable social gathering is for the reason for damage. Among the first questions requested pertain to how the machine works, and why the arm didn’t detect the particular person as they walked by way of the driveway.


Producers of most barrier arm gates construct their gadgets to activate in one in every of two alternative ways. Absolutely automated by distant stimulus and/or manually managed by a car parking zone attendant.

Many car parking zone management arms are activated when a driver pulls as much as a car parking zone gate in a car. Because the car arrives, an digital sign is shipped to the arm mechanism because of the detection of that autos giant metallic presence interacting with an in-ground magnetic subject. This

in- floor magnetic subject is created from buried wires identified within the commerce as an induction loop. The sign generated from this “activation or method magnetic induction flux loop” usually is related to a ticket printing machine. This piece of apparatus is often known as a “Ticket Spitter”. The “Spitter” points a ticket, normally for single car entry previous to activating the barrier arm gate mechanism inflicting the arm to boost. An alternate technique to get the management arm raised requires a driver to achieve out of the automotive and push a button to obtain a car parking zone entry ticket from the “Spitter”. (In that mode of operation, it’s possible that there isn’t a magnetic loop in place.) In both case, as soon as the ticket is taken by the motive force, the “Spitter” sends a management sign to the gate arm mechanism, and the arm is meant to boost, usually for a single car to manage entry to the car parking zone.

Because the car transitions from the method location the place the ticket is issued, as soon as the management arm raises, there may be normally a functioning magnetic flux or induction “Security Loop” positioned below the management arm swing location which supplies safety for a car till it has cleared the “Zone of Hazard” beneath the energetic arm. The management arm may additionally be saved within the open place by a timer that holds the gate arm up for a predetermined time previous to closing. Utilizing a timer perform instead of an in-ground magnetic loop is dangerous, as autos could not clear the opening, or one other car can try to realize entry with out receiving a utilization ticket. Older, non-current commonplace compliant installations have been seen with none consistency of design or operational perform.

There are a number of set up variables that may alter the essential loop positions and portions, however most simple programs function as described above utilizing no less than two management loops. One beneath the management arm, and one egress or method loop. In some installations, all three loops might be current. This triple looped system provides probably the most complete security for a car, NOT A PEDESTRIAN!


A car parking zone attendant, normally positioned inside an adjoining sales space, has a management change that prompts the parking arm. The attendant has a change that raises the arm, lowers the arm, and retains the arm inactive, both up or down. Some manually managed arms even have magnetic induction loops related to the car parking zone management arm when the car parking zone is unmanned after hours, by which case, the arm ought to perform within the absolutely computerized mode, as described above.


Opposite to standard perception, most are activated resulting from a change in a magnetic subject which is generated by twisted energized wires positioned under the adjoining pavement of the management arm. Fashionable arms are usually not normally managed by pneumatic strain like an old school fuel station bell hose. It’s unlikely that the load of a car or a pedestrian strolling beneath the arm will cease an energetic arm. Fashionable parking arms are triggered by a change within the magnetic induction loop return. Fashionable induction loops are manufactured from a comparatively gentle gauge of wire, positioned in an oblong form that’s calibrated and sized to detect a change within the magnetic subject when a metallic object similar to a car enters or covers that subject.

Many attorneys insist to me throughout their preliminary name {that a} pedestrian walked subsequent one and activated the arm resulting from their shopper’s weight, and the arm failed to stay open as they walked below the arm. This state of affairs is mostly incorrect. Weight of a car, or weight of a pedestrian can’t activate most trendy parking management arms. A set off of an arm or activation of a road visitors gentle resulting from weight has not been in follow for a few years. It’s extremely unlikely {that a} strain pad delicate to weight is ever controlling a car parking zone arm in the present day.

UL 325/ASTM F2200

There are a number of requirements which are used to design and set up parking management/barrier arm gadgets. In probably the most fundamental sense, UL 325 (Underwriters Laboratories) along with ASTM F2200 (American Society of Testing Supplies) in addition to different commerce organizations have compiled requirements which are designed to make a management/barrier arm set up secure and consumer pleasant. Many of the laws which are referenced in these requirements have been adopted and in frequent commerce follow and utilization for the reason that yr 2000. There are quite a few revisions of those requirements, and business finest practices for service suppliers and installers needs to be to deliver any of those previous put in merchandise updated with the most recent revision of the requirements for entrapment and performance.


A UL 325 compliant barrier arm or parking management arm set up requires a number of situations to be met. The mechanism is mostly put in atop a concrete island (not a UL requirement). All conduits and management circuits are routed into the bottom of the barrier arm mechanism by way of this elevated platform. This isn’t at all times the noticed scenario; nonetheless, it appears to be probably the most encountered situation because the elevated platform supplies safety from car affect for the arm housing. When this island is positioned by a concrete contractor, it’s the excellent time for the power to put in a devoted pedestrian walkway.

This devoted pedestrian walkway should be away from the “hazard zone” of the energetic management arm. This devoted pathway is without doubt one of the most vital components to having a UL 325 compliant set up. One other vital security machine required for a UL 325 compliant set up is blatant painted warnings on the pavement positioned adjoining to each side (ingress and egress) of the management arm. As an illustration: “Not a Pedestrian Walkway” or “Motor Automobiles Solely” together with vibrant stripes and designs to attract the eye of a pedestrian to point hazard previous to coming into the “hazard zone”. Signage can also be required, on the arm itself, the cupboard that homes the activation gear, and on a placard in entrance of the management arm gear.


I’ve noticed for a few years that pedestrians are sometimes strolling whereas distracted by their cell telephones, different individuals they’re engaged in dialog with, or low lighting situations. Though a UL requirement for a compliant set up is having a warning signal positioned in a number of areas adjoining to and hooked up to the management arm, that warning is usually unseen for a lot of causes. Pedestrians usually look to the placement that they’re planning to achieve with out seeing their rapid environment. When this happens, any warning signage has no worth to them. An indication that’s hooked up to a vertically elevated arm is out of the sector of view for a pedestrian generally in order that warning label is ineffective. A distracted pedestrian is as more likely to stroll off a curb in entrance of oncoming visitors or stroll below a raised parking management arm with out realizing that the hazard exists. Blatant pavement signage has additionally been ignored by distracted pedestrians centered on attending to the place they wish to go.


There are a selection of circumstances the place a car parking zone barrier arm has malfunctioned due to a whole lack of upkeep consciousness. Most producers counsel they need to be inspected and evaluated for perform by an expert service supplier no less than yearly. This interval inspection routine is questionable in a parking space with excessive utilization of the management arm. In a case of continuous utilization, an expert service supplier needs to be in place to examine the machine each quarter. Normally, some malfunction happens that requires skilled visits extra incessantly than each three or four months in a excessive utilization set up.

Generally property administration or an proprietor employs a upkeep particular person to make repairs. This may be problematic, as that upkeep particular person could not have satisfactory expertise or coaching as to the best way to correctly examine the features of the management arm mechanism and associated programs accurately. In different low utilization areas, the place the arm is both often used, unused and left in an open situation, or there may be minimal car parking zone exercise, property homeowners by no means get them serviced. They’re unaware of the necessity for service, really feel that the arm is working accurately when it’s used, or simply don’t wish to expense the companies of an expert resulting from budgetary constraints or an ignorance of how the machine features.

Most homeowners of parking management lot arms don’t perceive or have the abilities to correctly test all features of the arm management mechanism. They could be able to changing a damaged arm part when broken by a car, however hardly ever perceive the precise digital necessities. When a reliable, certified skilled service supplier is used to make proactive inspections of a parking management arm, there are quite a few assessments and digital evaluations which are made with devoted service gear that the typical gear proprietor wouldn’t possess.

One of the fundamental vital evaluations to make sure that a parking management arm is correctly functioning entails checking the resistance capability of the in-ground magnetic flux loops. These loops are one of many main controls for avoiding vehicular/arm affect collisions. There’s an digital meter often called a “megohm meter” or “meggar” that checks the situation of the in-ground loop insulation materials of all system loops. It measures hundreds of thousands of ohms of resistance by inserting a sign onto the flux loop when examined. The unbroken situation of the insulation that’s the outdoors coating of those in floor wires is crucial to have a correctly functioning flux loop.

Electrical leakage to the encircling floor resulting from partial lack of the protecting insulation creates false imaging to the controls of the parking arm gear. The insulation of those flux wire loops has an anticipated life. This is because of corrosive elements of the fabric that the wires are encased in. Concrete, asphalt, varied cement, sands and gravel all have corrosive parts to their chemical composition. These acids can have an effect on the lifetime of the flux wire insulation. Relying upon how a lot water leaches by way of the pavement, these flux wires will ultimately be uncovered to chemical substances that may break down the insulation safety that’s required. When that insulation breakdown lastly occurs, the operation of the magnetic flux loop is inconsistent and sometimes turns into a hazard to autos of every kind (automobiles, vehicles, bikes, bicycles, trailers, and so on.) utilizing the management arm.

Faulty operation of car parking zone management programs has been incessantly noticed following flooding resulting from pushed rains or adjoining sprinkler programs. In a number of previous circumstances, service suppliers and homeowners that did not take vital assessments to find out insulation high quality of magnetic loops have been chargeable for injury brought on on account of these unknown wire situations. In some claims, the service supplier was conscious that the loops weren’t functioning as much as specs of the loop producer but did not take any proactive motion to have them changed, or minimally alert the proprietor of the arm that the situation existed. To save cash, some service suppliers fabricate their very own loops for these installations. When that’s the case, the service supplier must often confirm the situation of the loops to make sure that the efficiency is as required.


It’s normally a objective to make a product that’s as secure as is feasible for all customers. The UL 325 requirements try and hold present with technological advances however are usually not at all times updated. Fundamental necessities as described above do make management arms moderately secure, however there are further security gadgets that may be added to most parking management programs.

  • Cross threshold optical sensor beams. These beams perform in the identical manner {that a} frequent residential computerized storage door backside beam sensor works. They supply an extra safety to each autos and pedestrians as they cease the management arm from descending when the beam is obstructed. To be efficient, they must be correctly positioned and in sufficient amount.
  • Audible alarms are being put in to alert pedestrians and drivers in proximity to the management arm that it’s about to descend.
  • Seen alarms that present strobe or flashing gentle motion alert pedestrians and drivers that the barrier arm is about to descend.
  • Contact security switches hooked up to the underside fringe of a parking management arm trigger the descending arm to reverse when 10 kilos of power from an obstruction happens.

These added security gadgets are usually not a part of any commonplace requirement however are comparatively cheap so as to add to a management arm system and are typically simpler in warning pedestrians that one thing is about to occur. Each alarms start working just a few seconds earlier than any activation motion of the arm begins. A correctly positioned beam or beams may be efficient in stopping the descent of a management arm when a pedestrian is obstructing the beam however isn’t absolutely dependable resulting from consumer interactions. It’s best follow to keep away from having any pedestrian stroll below the pathway of a management arm.


Many bike accidents from parking arms have occurred as a direct results of magnetic loop degeneration. Correctly working management loops ought to have sufficient sensitivity to “discover” most metallic objects. I’ve been capable of take a look at magnetic fields for gates and management arms utilizing a one-foot sq. piece of sheet metal with optimistic outcomes which have activated the gadgets. Automobiles and vehicles clearly have bigger footprints than a motorbike, scooter or bicycle, but when the loops are delicate sufficient and the module that controls these loops is correctly adjusted, it’s not unreasonable to get a sufficiently big change within the magnetic subject to set off the operator mechanism. Until there are particular entry and egress factors for bikes and different two wheeled conveyances, most riders will anticipate {that a} management arm will react to their rides. It’s critically vital to have competent skilled service suppliers consider management arm programs frequently. Modifications to sensitivity of the magnetic fields that may happen immediately create issues leading to beauty injury to automobiles however could cause catastrophic harmful situations for 2 wheeled autos. Bike accidents with barrier arms are significantly harmful when the security loops which are positioned below the management arm fail or work intermittently. A rider will acquire entry, the arm will elevate, and with out warning it should descend into the face or on prime of the top of the rider resulting in probably extreme accidents. It’s a affordable expectation on the a part of a motorbike operator that the arm will stay open and the in-ground loops will detect the presence of a motorbike. Harmful situations that exist on account of deferred or non-existent upkeep of parking management arms have created many bike rider affect damage claims.



When there isn’t a proactive upkeep of any machine or piece of apparatus in a facility the proprietor is negligent for failing to take the time to make sure that the property might be secure for all invitees. Failing to make use of competent skilled service suppliers resulting from price, ignorance, laziness or stupidity is negligent. Having correctly maintained and correctly working gear is accountable and meets the usual of care anticipated of an proprietor that invitations the general public on to the property. Having a proactive plan to offer inspections and upkeep of all gear is accountable and diligent. If the skilled service supplier has not met the usual of care, the proprietor could in the end have the accountability for the faulty situation of the management arm. Whether or not or not there may be an indemnification coverage between the service supplier and proprietor can decide who’s financially chargeable for the damage declare. If the proprietor has been knowledgeable of operational or purposeful deficiencies by others and has refused to improve or make the management arm commonplace compliant, it’s extra possible than not that the proprietor will turn into a accountable social gathering.


If an expert service supplier doesn’t make the property proprietor conscious of adjustments in requirements or advise the proprietor of potential security upgrades, that skilled isn’t appearing as much as business expectations. The service supplier can also be not taking the chance for elevated gross sales revenues derived from making these options. If a service supplier has supplied restricted companies to an proprietor (similar to an on-call / as-needed foundation), it’s onerous to position the blame on the service supplier that was simply offering particular work. It’s nonetheless really useful that every one deficiencies in an working barrier arm system be recognized, specified, and described in order that the service supplier can switch the legal responsibility onto the proprietor of the now non-compliant management arm.

When an expert service supplier installs a parking management arm in a non-compliant set up (for instance there isn’t a devoted walkway or signage), the obligations for that deficiency depend on the communication and dealing relationship with the proprietor of the property. There are a number of totally different eventualities that decide the accountable events for the non-compliant situations.

  • Was the service supplier solely referred to as upon to put in a selected product?
  • Was the service supplier restricted by the proprietor of the property to solely do a specified job?
  • Did the service supplier make the proprietor conscious of the deficiencies of the set up previous to, throughout or after the work was carried out?
  • Did the service supplier try and make the set up present commonplace compliant, however was advised to not?
  • What portion of the set up was the service supplier concerned with? For instance, the service supplier was contracted by a basic contractor and advised to particularly present a portion of the merchandise required to make the set up compliant. The representations made by the overall contractor was that the overall would place all indicators when the venture was turned over to the proprietor, the overall would have acceptable pavement warnings painted and positioned when the paving was accomplished, and the overall would set up a devoted stroll manner for pedestrians at a later date.

If the service supplier acted in a commerce acceptable method, fulfilled all duties and obligations informing the proprietor or administration of the non-compliant situations encountered, that service supplier has met the business commonplace of care. In that case, the service supplier isn’t chargeable for a non- compliant management arm set up.



This situation has been seen so many occasions that a number of accidents had been brought on in the very same manner. In a number of previous claims, a pedestrian was primarily pressured to stroll below a parking management arm as a result of there was no different strategy to exit the lot or storage area. There was no devoted pedestrian walkway, no openings in a fence, no indicated paths for individuals to exit, no particular stairways or different technique of egress, and in these circumstances, the management arm was unavoidable. In different claims, a remotely operated management arm, that was activated by a guard in an adjoining hut got here down upon a number of pedestrians because of the guard being careless. The gate was routinely in an upright place, the guard by no means meant to have the gate shut upon the pedestrians, but the damage befell as a direct results of the guard’s negligence.


A bunch of pedestrians strolling right into a live performance venue walked below a management arm, which got here down simply as they walked below it. There was loads of area on both facet of the management arm, however there was no signage or painted warnings on the pavement exhibiting the place the arm may come down.

A pedestrian going to work in a hospital, brought on her personal damage. She watched as a automotive went by way of the management arm entry level and didn’t notice that the gate would shut upon her. In her deposition statements she stated she thought that the arm would keep up as a result of she had seen different individuals stroll by way of the identical opening prior to now with out the arm descending. There was a devoted walkway just a few ft away from the place this incident occurred, going by way of the car path was a shortcut that saved just a few steps and brought on her main damage.

Tenant of an residence advanced will get hit with management arm gate after serving to a neighbor acquire entry when the neighbor had forgotten her card key entry cross. The injured social gathering stood adjoining to the management arm, swiped her entry card, watched her pal drive by way of the opening after which with out thought proceeded into the lot following the automotive. As soon as the automotive cleared the magnetic loops, the arm descended as designed, solely it struck the tenant, knocking her out solely seconds after her good deed.


Management arms are designed for limiting the circulate of autos into or out of a location that wishes regulation of visitors. The gear features primarily based upon activation alerts acquired as described above. Entry factors which have management arms are usually not supposed for pedestrian visitors at any time. Whereas most autos are metallic, most pedestrians are non-metallic. The machines that function these management arms are dumb robots with none capabilities of intervention within the occasion of a non- conforming use. A pedestrian trying to stroll by way of a parking management arm location is a non- conforming use, and there should be some frequent sense exercised when assessing an interplay with any robotic machine.


All homeowners which have public, business, or residential neighborhood properties can anticipate utilization by 1000’s of various individuals. If proactive upkeep and analysis of the placement setting in addition to the situation of the gear that folks work together with is made routinely, an proprietor can take the wanted steps to maintain the property in a fairly secure situation. An proprietor ought to enlist the companies of certified and competent service suppliers to make sure that every one entry management arms are correctly functioning, and the positioning is completely compliant. If an proprietor takes accountability and hires skilled service suppliers to make a property absolutely compliant, that proprietor has met his obligations to all invitees of the property. Failing to proactively consider a probably harmful situation is negligent. Upkeep saves cash in the long term. Holding gear of every kind in good situation is accountable and signifies good possession. Security to all invitees needs to be of prime significance to a involved proprietor.


Magnetic induction flux loop: A wire of particular dimension and design positioned under the pavement floor to create a magnetic subject which is altered when a metallic object (car) is in proximity or on prime of the wire subject.

Ticket Spitter: A printing machine used to dispense parking tickets to patrons of a car parking zone. Guide (push button by consumer) or computerized (triggered by presence of car on prime of magnetic loop in floor), information date and time of entry onto a paper ticket after which when faraway from the slot prompts a management arm mechanism to realize entry into the lot.

Management arm machine: All digital and mechanical gear mixed to permit a gate arm to boost and decrease.

Method loop: Magnetic loop positioned in floor to set off activation of a management machine.

Security Loop: Magnetic loop positioned instantly below the trail of a parking management arm to guard autos from affect by a descending gate arm when the zone is occupied by a car.

Egress loop: Magnetic loop positioned in floor to carry a management machine within the open place till the realm may be cleared. Normally in place in excessive visitors or cross visitors places.

Megohm meter (Megger): An digital meter designed to find out resistance in hundreds of thousands of ohms, related to this text, checking for leakage because of the breaking down of insulation on in floor magnetic flux loop wires used to manage parking management arm actions.

Zone of Hazard: The world instantly below the trail of a descending parking management arm and any rapid space the place a pedestrian could possibly be struck by a descending arm with out discover.


Parking Management arm accidents happen incessantly. These accidents are sometimes the results of a deferred or non-standard set up or upkeep protocol. They happen equally to straightforward compliant installations when pedestrians simply don’t pay sufficient consideration to their environment.


Source by Michael Panish

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to Top